Lindsay Clancy: What Should Be Our Focus?

Nov 21st, 2026 | By | Category: Featured Issues, Politics & Current Events

The mission of Issues in Perspective is to provide thoughtful, historical and biblically-centered perspectives on current ethical and cultural issues.

On 24 January 2023, Lindsay Clancy fatally strangled her three children: five-year-old Cora, three-year-old Dawson, and eight-month-old Callan—at the family’s home in Duxbury, Massachusetts. She then cut her wrists and neck and jumped from a second-story window, sustaining injuries that left her paralyzed from the waist down.

Before she strangled her children, Lindsay Clancy had seen her psychiatrist 14 times, tried 13 different medications, called a suicide hotline, went to an emergency room, tried to enroll in an inpatient program, and confided to her husband that she had had thoughts of harming her children. Defense experts testified that doctors had missed an underlying bipolar disorder and prescribed pills that made Clancy’s symptoms worse, starting a downward spiral that culminated in a rare condition called postpartum psychosis that can cause hallucinations. Clancy has said that she heard a male voice telling her to kill her children, Cora, Dawson, and Callan, on 24 January 2023.

Massachusetts prosecutors have argued that Clancy acted rationally and with clear intent, noting that she seemed organized, reasonable, and communicative in the days leading up to the murders, according to witnesses. Clancy’s diary entries and help-seeking indicate that she knew that her desire to harm herself and others was wrong, yet on the day that she apparently intended to kill her children, Clancy asked her then-husband to run an errand that would keep him out of the house. “But the symptoms of postpartum psychosis, like those of bipolar disorder and schizoaffective disorder, are known to involve sudden and dramatic fluctuations, meaning that Clancy’s moods and cognition could have changed rapidly in the run-up to the murders—in defiance of most legal tests of insanity.”

Lindsay was prosecuted for three counts of murder in a criminal trial that began on 20 July 2026. Although she did not deny killing her children, her defense argued that she had been suffering from postpartum psychosis and bipolar disorder and therefore lacked criminal responsibility. Much of the trial focused on her mental health in the months before the deaths, during which she repeatedly sought treatment for symptoms including insomnia, intrusive thoughts, and suicidal ideation. Prosecutors alleged that Lindsay was mentally aware at the time of the killings and that her actions beforehand, including sending her husband out on an errand, demonstrated methodical planning. They emphasized that she reported hearing the commanding voice only on the day of the killings and that none of her clinicians reported observing psychosis. On September 4, the judge declared a mistrial in the Lindsay Clancy case, the result of one holdout juror who prevented a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity.

In the New Yorker, Jessica Winter argues that “It was inevitable, owing to our present political and sociocultural moment, and to the bottomless horror of the facts of this case, that the Clancy trial would inspire outlandish counternarratives. The American public distrusts its legal institutions and media outlets, creating a vacuum in which wild conjecture can bloom. True-crime brain is a national epidemic. And trying to comprehend how an outwardly loving and devoted mother could asphyxiate her own children, one by one, using exercise resistance bands, while her husband ran errands, might trigger a kind of bewitched disbelief—one that expresses itself in perverse acts of fixation-by-deflection, including, to cite one example, staging a speculative reenactment of the crime scene using Bratz dolls and then posting it to TikTok.”

This trial was never about whether Clancy killed her three children. Her defense conceded that right off the bat. As Josh Wood of the journal First Things argues, “The question they raised was whether she could be held criminally responsible for the acts she committed. Jed Rubenfeld, a professor of constitutional law at Yale, explains in the Free Press that in most of the country, and in federal court, a defendant who pleads insanity has to prove it. Massachusetts is one of about a dozen states that do it the other way around. Once the defense raises the question, the burden is on the Commonwealth to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that she was criminally responsible. As Rubenfeld put it in an interview, ‘How do you prove a negative?’ Both sides had experts. Some were certain she was psychotic. Others were certain she was not. This stacked the deck in favor of acquittal. The more brutal the act is, the easier it is to argue that no sane person could have done it. Clancy’s lawyers never had to prove she was insane. They had to make only one person wonder. Turns out they got eleven.”

Wood: “This is backward. A woman who confesses to killing her children should carry the burden of showing she was not criminally responsible. Most states and the federal government agree. And Massachusetts did not inherit its rule from some distant century. Its highest court adopted its current insanity test in 1967. But here’s what worries me more than the Clancy outcome. Almost nobody outside that courtroom knows that Massachusetts flips the burden of proof. What the country will remember is that eleven Americans heard the evidence in the worst case imaginable and said Clancy could not be held responsible. The women who lined up outside the courthouse, and those who vociferated in her defense around the country, now celebrate the court’s protecting the one they view as the primary victim.”

Wood adds several additional insights to this case:

  • Within hours of the mistrial, Postpartum Support International, which calls itself “the nation’s leading nonprofit dedicated to perinatal mental health,” pledged to keep pushing “for laws in every state that treat these mothers as patients.” And it named its models: “more than two dozen countries, including England, Canada, and Australia,” whose infanticide laws “direct these mothers toward psychiatric care rather than prison.” The Maternal Mental Health Leadership Alliance made the same case four days later.
  • The decline of Canada’s legal system reveals what happens when we create our laws around the wrong victim. In 1948, Canada’s Parliament created a special category for the mother who kills her child while her mind is “disturbed” by childbirth. The thought of jailing a poor young mother for the entirety of her natural life was too much for juries. John Diefenbaker, a member of Parliament who would later become prime minister, said it plainly: “Over and over again juries have refused to convict, regardless of the evidence. I presume that the reason for this amendment is to make it easier to get a conviction.” Rather than find jurors who would apply the law as written, Parliament rewrote the law to match what jurors were already willing to do.
  • Kirsten Kramar, a sociologist who defends the law, told the Edmonton Journal in 2006 that no Canadian woman had been jailed for longer than a year for murdering her child since 1948. Convicted mothers, she said, usually get no jail time at all. Kramar was responding to an Alberta case, where Katrina Effert offered to plead guilty to infanticide, but the Crown refused and tried her for murder. She was convicted by two separate juries of murder for strangling her newborn son with her underwear, then tossing his body over a fence. She was sentenced to life imprisonment. Then in 2011, an appeals court substituted infanticide, and Justice Joanne Veit handed down a suspended three-year sentence.

With this overview, let’s come back to the Clancy case. Massachusetts built a law that makes convictions in these cases next to impossible, and then a case came along that put the result on national television for months. As Wood observes, “This fateful confluence of events will undoubtedly become a cultural catechesis, encouraging blind support of all postpartum women in cases of infanticide, with no consideration of whether psychosis was truly at play. In a society dependent on the worldview of our neighbors, who fill our jury pools, this should scare all of us. If that contagion does its work, we will end up where Canada is now: with a category of cases in which juries refuse to convict, and, if Postpartum Support International gets its way, new laws that start us down the slippery slope toward a world that makes justice impossible for the murdered child. Instead, we should demand that Massachusetts reckon with a legal standard that requires the state to prove a woman responsible for a murder she confesses to committing. It is an inversion that treats her as the presumptive victim and asks her children to earn a verdict, when the one fact nobody disputes is that she killed them.”

The fundamental takeaway from the Clancy case in the context of Massachusetts law is that “We should center the child instead. Make justice for the child the default. Then let the woman who was truly psychotic prove it and receive the relief she deserves. Mercy earned through proof is justice. Mercy by default, after a murder confession, is immunity. However we respond after this decision, our choice of victim will determine our future.”

See Josh Wood, “Lindsay Clancy and America’s Canadian Future” in First Things (26 September 2026); Jessica Winter, “Wy People Want to Believe the Lindsay Clancy Conspiracy Theories: in The New Yorker (22 August 2026); Elizabeth Bruenig, “Why Lindsay Clancy’s Insanity Defense Might Fail” in The Atlantic (17 August 2026).

Leave a Comment